Our content is free because we earn a commission when you click or make a purchase from links on our site. Learn more about how we make money.

Healthy Paws vs. Embrace Pet Insurance

Healthy Paws and Embrace are two of the top pet insurance companies in the United States.

Both offer excellent coverage, competitive pricing, and excellent service.

While both are popular and offer comprehensive services, there are some differences.

Our in-depth review will cover their differences as well as their various plans and coverage.

Healthy Paws vs. Embrace Comparison – The Highlights

Healthy Paws is on everyone’s top 10 list, and there’s a reason why!

healthy paws vs embrace
All of their plans have unlimited benefits, so you never have to worry about hitting a maximum in vet bills.

With competitive pricing, standard waiting lists, and many reimbursement choices, any pet owner can budget their monthly premiums with ease.

It’s also helpful to know that the BBB has ranked Healthy Paws with an A+ rating.

>>Get Healthy Paws Quote Now<<

Embrace is known for excellent customer service and happy policyholders.

Their pricing is a little on the higher end, but their comprehensive insurance plans are very inclusive with alternative therapy and wellness choices.

The benefit limits for Healthy Paws cap at $15,000, which can be limiting if your pet gets in a serious accident.

Coverage Compared In-Depth

Healthy Paws and Embrace both offer very inclusive and well-rounded coverage, while Embrace also offers wellness plans.

Healthy Paws offers all types of treatments, including:

  • Alternative Therapy including Physical Therapy
  • Chiropractic Care
  • Hydrotherapy

All congenital and hereditary conditions are covered, including cancer.

With all these services and unlimited benefits, their coverage could be considered all-inclusive.

Embrace’s standard plan also covers:

  • Alternative Therapy
  • Prosthetics
  • Behavioral Therapy (which most insurers don’t typically include)

They have an advantage over Healthy Paws by including the vet exam fee, which is unique among providers.

While their benefit limit is $30,000 maximum in all states online except NY (where it’s $15,000), they do offer many deductible and reimbursement choices so policyholders can budget accordingly.

Embrace offers unlimited coverage in most states via phone enrollment.

If wellness plans are of interest, Embrace offers three different plans from $250 to $650.

It is an allowance towards most preventative care routines. There is, of course, an extra cost for these services, which is an add-on to the policy you choose.

Embrace also includes holistic and alternative therapies including acupuncture, chiropractic care, physical therapy, hydrotherapy and laser therapy.

Benefit Limits Compared

Healthy Paws has the advantage when it comes to benefit limits as they have no cap at all in all of their plans, while Embrace only offers unlimited coverage in most states via phone enrollment.

Healthy Paws doesn’t have a limit on how much you can spend on your pet each year or even throughout the life of your pet.

These unlimited caps are even in Healthy Paws’ most basic plan.

If your pet has a serious disease or needs emergency care, it’s a relief to know that there isn’t a cap on the vet bills for the year.  You can rightfully worry about your pet and not the cost!

Embrace’s plans, however, have limits of $30,000 in all states online except NY where it’s $15,000.  While these ranges help control the premium costs, it can be extremely restricting if your pet has a big medical bill.

Keep in mind, however, that Embrace offers unlimited coverage in most states via phone enrollment.

Deductibles Compared

Healthy Paws and Embrace both works on an annual deductible and not per-incident.

An annual deductible works by you choosing a deductible amount each policy year.

This will be the first payment you make before any reimbursement is distributed by the pet insurance provider.

With Healthy Paws, you have a few choices of deductibles that range from a low of $100 to a high of $500.

If you want your premium to be lower, then choose a deductible on the higher end of the range.

embrace vs healthy paws

Embrace offers many choices of deductibles which include the following amounts: $200, $500, $750, and even $1000 to help cater a plan to your budget needs.

Embrace’s Healthy Pet Deductible lowers policyholders’ deductibles by $50 for every policy year that they don’t receive a reimbursement, which is a great perk.

As with any annual deductible, you pay it once a year and it resets at the beginning of the policy year.

>>Get Embrace Quote Now<<

Reimbursements Compared

Both Healthy Paws and Embrace have flexibility in their reimbursement choices that are paid off the actual medical bill (always the best choice).

Healthy Paws has the following reimbursement levels:

  • 70%
  • 80%
  • 90%

If you choose the lowest reimbursement level of 70%, you will have a lower premium.

Embrace has the following reimbursement level choices:

  • 70%
  • 80%
  • 90%

And with the Wellness rewards, they will reimburse you an allowance ranging from $250 to $650 depending on the plan you choose.

Pricing Compared

Healthy Paws and Embrace are both competitively priced.

While Embrace’s prices are lower for younger pets, the unlimited benefits in all of Healthy Paws plans make your dollar go much further, as compared to Embrace’s unlimited annual maximums offered in most states only via phone enrollments.

Healthy Paws offers many discounts that can help lower your bill:

A 10% premium reduction for the following:

  • Animal Welfare Volunteers
  • Alumni Organizations
  • AAA, AARP, and Costco Members
  • Military Service

A 15% lifetime discount (which can add up!) for employee plans.

Healthy Paws’ monthly premiums for dogs start at $27 while cats start at $17.

Embrace offers discounts for the following:  

  • Neutered or spayed cats and dogs (5% discount only available in NY)
  • Enrolling multiple pets (discount is 10% in all states except NY, where it is 5%)
  • $12 discount for paying the entire year up front
  • Military members (5% in most states)
  • Direct payment from your bank (only in NY)

You can further adjust your premiums with one of their many deductible choices.

Embrace’s monthly premiums for dogs start at $14 while cats start at $9.

Claims and Service Compared

Healthy Paws and Embrace have very positive reviews and are known for their great customer service.

Healthy Paws can boast and rightfully so about their claims being paid back within 5 days. And with policy members enjoying the ease at which claims are fulfilled.

Healthy Paws customer service is always available –24/7!

Embrace is equally praised by their policyholders for the ease of which their claims are fulfilled.

You simply can upload your invoice through their online portal, MyEmbrace, where you can even see the status. Most claims are reimbursed within 2 weeks.

If you have any questions about your pet’s health, Embrace’s PawSupport is available around the clock and give you access to vet experts.

It’s a nice addition if you have any questions about your dog or cat’s health.

Enrollment and Waiting Periods Compared

healthy paws vs embrace pet insurance policiesHealthy Paws and Embrace’s waiting periods and age limits are very similar and standard of the industry.

Healthy Paws waiting period for accidents is 5 days and illness is 15 days, while hip dysplasia has a one-year waiting period.

Puppies and kittens can enroll at eight weeks, and the upper age limit is 13 years.

You don’t need your pet’s medical records to enroll.

Embrace’s waiting periods are 2 days for accidents and 14 days for illnesses.

A 6-month waiting period is required for orthopedic conditions, but if you talk to your vet before enrolling and all is clear, the waiting period can be reduced to 14 days.

Puppies and kittens can be enrolled at six weeks, and the upper age limit is 14 years.

Summing It All Up

Healthy Paws and Embrace are both top providers that offer all you can want in coverage.

Healthy Paws has the advantage of the unlimited benefit options that Embrace only offers in most states via phone enrollment, and Embrace gives a few more choices of deductibles, reimbursements, and wellness plans, if that is of interest to you.

Of course, the choice is yours.   Get a list of questions ready and get quotes from each of them to see which caters best to your pet and your budget.

And, of course, if you are interested in comparing other pet insurance companies or getting some further quotes, our top 10 pet insurance companies for 2020 will give you some other excellent providers!

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply