Nationwide and Trupanion are two of the largest pet insurers in the United States. Nationwide is highly recognized as the first pet insurer in the country, but Trupanion is gaining brand recognition as they grab more of the market share. But none of that matters to you as a pet owner. All that matters is that your pet is going to be protected if something bad happens to them.
If you are in the process of shopping for pet insurance, you have probably already looked at both Nationwide and Trupanion. Determining which is best is going to depend on your budget, your pet, and your overall insurance needs. There are a variety of factors to consider in order to determine which is the best choice for you.
Read our comprehensive comparison below to understand the difference between Nationwide and Trupanion pet insurance.
Trupanion vs. Nationwide: Coverage Comparison
Trupanion Pet Insurance Coverage
Trupanion has a long, established history of offering good coverage to its customers. They offer a single plan with a flexible choice of deductible with 90% reimbursement and an unlimited annual limit. It covers major medical expenses such as accidents and illnesses, and you can adjust the deductible to help make your monthly payments more manageable.
Trupanion also offers an optional rider called the “Recovery and Complementary Care Rider coverage.” It helps with costs related to recovery after medical or surgical therapies. This can include acupuncture, homeopathy, hydrotherapy, and even behavior modification.
There are varied waiting periods before coverage kicks in based on the type of coverage. There is a 5-day waiting period for accident coverage, and a 30-day waiting period for illness and orthopedic coverage.
Unfortunately, wellness coverage is not offered by Trupanion, and they also offer no coverage for exam fees. Additionally, they consider any accidents or illness that occurred up to 18 months before you purchase the policy a preexisting condition. This means that if your pet continues to have issues due to a recent accident, those costs will not be covered by your Trupanion policy.
Nationwide Pet Insurance Coverage
Nationwide offers customers a choice of three plans:
- Whole Pet with Wellness plan
- Major Medical plan
- Pet Wellness plan
Whole Pet with Wellness
The Whole Pet with Wellness plan is a comprehensive plan that provides coverage for accidents and illnesses in addition to a range of wellness and routine coverages. This plan is best for those that want to cover the full spectrum of pet medical expenses.
Major Medical Plan
The Major Medical plan offers full or partial coverage for accident and illness costs. This plan will appeal to those that can cover routine costs but want to make sure that they are covered in case of accidents or injuries.
Pet Wellness Plan
Lastly, the Pet Wellness plan offers coverage for a handful of routine costs but excludes major medical expenses. This plan is best for those that want the routine costs covered but believe that they can handle a major medical cost should it occur.
Nationwide considers congenital conditions pre-existing. Unfortunately, this means that there is a wide range of conditions that may not be covered under Nationwide’s policy, including skin conditions, hip dysplasia, and even cancer.
Much like Trupanion, Nationwide also offers 90% reimbursement. Their annual limits begin at $10,000 and have no upper limit. They also have the same waiting period of 14 days for accidents, illnesses, and orthopedic coverage, which means that your insurance will kick in for everything after two weeks.
Trupanion vs. Nationwide: Price Comparison
Trupanion is slightly more expensive than Nationwide. On average, dog owners will pay about $68 per month, and cat owners will pay roughly $59 per month for pet insurance. Deductibles range from $0 to $1,000, which is a wide range for a pet insurance company.
Trupanion’s premiums are generally fair and right down the middle. They have low annual increases, and annual premium increases don’t grow as a pet ages.
Nationwide Pet Insurance Pricing
Of the two, Nationwide is the less expensive option. On average, customers pay anywhere from $39 to $65 per month for their insurance policies. Nationwide also charges a $2 monthly transaction fee that is included in their pricing.
The prices for Nationwide will vary based on which of their three plan options you choose to go with. Unlike Trupanion, Nationwide does not offer additional coverages that can be added to your policy, so you won’t have as much opportunity to customize your coverage or pricing in this regard.
Trupanion vs. Nationwide: Claims Comparison
Trupanion Claims Process
Most pet insurance providers require that you pay for the bill upfront and then file a claim to get reimbursement. Instead, Trupanion offers to pay veterinarians and animal hospitals directly so that you don’t have to pay out of pocket. This is unique compared to most pet insurance companies and is good for people that may not have funds available to front a large vet bill.
Trupanion has a deductible that can go up to $1,000. This means that you are going to be responsible for a larger portion of the expense. However, they do not have any annual or lifetime caps for reimbursement. Reimbursement is based on your actual veterinary bills rather than an estimated average cost.
Nationwide Pet Insurance Claims Process
Nationwide, like many pet insurance companies, reimburses you only after you have already paid a veterinary bill. Additionally, payouts are according to a schedule of benefits, unless you opt into the most expensive plan.
Despite this, Nationwide is more affordable than Trupanion for cases that are covered under the policy. Under Nationwide’s policies, every claim is eligible for a deductible, which maxes out at $250 per incident. This means that you will never have to pay more than this for incidences covered by your policy.
Trupanion vs. Nationwide: Which is Best for You?
Both companies offer comparable levels of coverage, but Trupanion will cover more illnesses than Nationwide. Trupanion views accidents or illnesses that have occurred within 18 months prior to coverage as pre-existing conditions. After that, it is considered a new condition.
Nationwide is less lenient when it comes to pre-existing conditions. Many conditions, such as certain cancers and illnesses, will be lumped into the pre-existing condition category regardless of whether it has existed in your pet prior to coverage. If the breed has a history of congenital issues, they may be less likely to cover issues with your pet.
This does not mean that Trupanion is going to be the best choice for everyone. Nationwide offers wellness coverage, which means that they are going to offer some coverage for annual examinations, shots, and other routine expenses. If you are interested in your pet insurance kicking in for wellness expenses, Nationwide might be a better option for you.
Ultimately, the right pet insurance comes down to your and your pet’s specific needs. If worse comes to worst, you want to make sure that your pet is protected and your wallet is intact. This requires understanding what your pet is at risk for, what your policy will cover, and how much you are required to front before coverage kicks in.
To learn more about pet insurance and finding the right policy for you, check out some of our popular articles for more information.